That Crime of the Month

Ladies: in your lifetimes, you will spend an average of 1400 days on your period; and get through an average of 125-150kgs of sanitary towels or tampons.

Yikes!

Periods. Yay.

Periods. Yay.

Enfin, when I say ‘you’, that’s making three enormous presumptions:

1) That you have money to pay for sanitary towels/tampons;

2) That there are some available to buy;

3) That you have somewhere to dispose of them afterwards.

How many of us have ever had to think about any of those questions?

Menstruation, I think we all agree, is not fun.  You’re a girl, you hit puberty, you start bleeding every month.  Urgh.  It’s messy, it’s painful, it takes you a few years to get the hang of it, we probably all have that awful never-publicly-admitted story of the time the period came on early (and you were wearing white) or late (and you were scared you were pregnant).

But we manage. By way of contraception that diminishes or eliminates periods entirely; or by way of that aisle in the supermarket only ever visited by women, filled with masses of white fluffy pads and (now usually brightly coloured – eh?) tampons of all shapes and sizes.

Imagine that all taken away.  What would you do? How would you go about your daily life? Work? Study? Travel? Sleep at night?

That is the hush-hush situation of millions of women worldwide in poorer countries, who face their monthly period not with exasperation and a bit of PMT, but fearfully: without any reliable way of absorbing the flow (disposable pads often too expensive or inexistent), or keeping themselves clean during their menses.

For girls still at school, this means skipping classes; not only for fear of leakage/stains, but also given a lack of sanitary facilities.  For example, one study showed that 66% of schools in India did not have a functioning toilet.  And even if toilets are available, studies show they are too few (1 toilet per 600 students in Nigeria); lacking doors, running water or soap (essential for flushing away blood, cleaning hands, or washing reusable pads).

Poor sanitary facilities, of course, is a bane for all students (not just girls or female teachers) but imagine not having access to a toilet during your period.  You can hardly go behind a bush; where do you put your soiled sanitary towel or tampon? And if you have an accident, how do you wash out the stain, before you are teased (best case scenario) or ostracized (commonly reported) by male classmates or even teachers?

Because periods are not just a practical nightmare in developing countries.  Research shows that menstruating girls and women are seen as “dirty”, “shameful” or “polluting”; many are forcibly excluded from everyday activities such as prayer, preparing food, socialising, sleeping in their own beds.

With that in mind, it’s understandable that a young woman will prefer to stay away from school altogether during her period.

The problem is, she won’t just be missing school on one occasion.  Our periods, as we blissfully know, come once a month.  Every month.  Twelve times a year, every year, beginning on average at the age of 13 (“menarche”). That is potentially a lot of missed schooling.

Even though there is a real lack of reliable quantitative evidence on how menstrual hygiene management (MHM) impacts girls’ attendance at school, qualitative studies clearly indicate the link between having knowledge (“software”) or supplies (“hardware”) and the likelihood of making the commute to and from a long day at school.

This is why UNESCO estimates that one in ten girls in Africa will eventually drop out of school as a result of their periods.

One in ten. 10% of the next generation of women, slipping out of schooling because of their period.  This with the knowledge that two-thirds of all illiterate adults today are still women; and knowing also that gender parity for school enrollment remains a utopic vision (despite progress made via the Millennium Development Goals), given continued social norms around girls’ role as carers in the home, or the economic value of investing in girls’ education with limited household budgets.

Without schooling: fewer qualifications, fewer job opportunities, higher likelihood of early or forced marriage, knock-on effects in terms of income, health, children’s health, wider economy… et j’en passe.

So what is being done about it?

Hmm.  Not much, actually.  (surprised?)

At least, not on the scale necessary.  There are some dedicated movements, such as the charity 50 Cents.Period; and other NGOs have sought to incorporate/advocate principles on MHM into their broader work, especially on water and sanitation.  Other research institutions such as J-PAL are investigating which “hardware” solutions could help, including the menstrual cup or reusable pads.

Afripad. Photo credits: ImpactAlpha.com

Afripad. Photo credits: ImpactAlpha.com

So there is some mainstreaming.  And growing recognition of the issue, and of the need for more and better research.

Oh, and a new international day for menstrual hygiene, in case you missed it – 28 May.  Have a look at the interesting Facebook page that’s promoting it (and put it in your diary for next year).

But that’s about it.  Why so little interest?

Well, first up, periods make people uncomfortable.  Admit it – you’ve not been enjoying this post very much, have you? (if you’ve got this far, keep going.  You’re almost there.)  There are thousands of years of social myth, religious connotation, mystery associated to a woman’s monthly cycle.  Even without these, we all are squeamish about blood, and especially menstrual blood – like, beurk.

But those attitudes are not only old-fashioned, they are damaging.  Young girls discover periods without understanding what they are or having any way of managing them, because talking about them is taboo.  Even my own mother, in nice middle-class developed-country England, did not give me any heads-up; I can tell you, it wasn’t a nice surprise.

Managing menstruation is also taboo (and expensive).  Given the lack of materials, women resort to whatever they can find to prevent or mitigate the flow: leaves, mud, tree bark.  Which of course is inefficient, not to mention uncomfortable and ultimately risks bacterial infection.

Second up, periods are a women’s issue.  Now, (I know! no generalisations! I promised!) by and large, that means that in structures where power, budgets and decision-making are managed by men and not women, the issue will be given less or no consideration because it simply isn’t something that men have to contend with (a bit like whoever designed the metro cheerfully forgetting disabled users or parents hefting prams).

For some donors, and some developing country governments, forgetting about periods is an oversight they’re willing to correct. For others, menstruation is surrounded by so much cultural and social stigma, that it will never be a priority (amongst all the other pressing priorities).

For example, the new global development framework, the Sustainable Development Goals (to be agreed in September 2015) doesn’t address menstruation – or at least not specifically.  The only relevant target in the current draft is:

6.2  By 2030, achieve access to adequate and equitable sanitation and hygiene for all and end open defecation, paying special attention to the needs of women and girls and those in vulnerable situations

Not overly prescriptive, you will agree.

Which is a shame.

No, wait, it’s much, much more than just a shame.  As Ashlee Betteridge sums up neatly:

“…just because women and girls cope doesn’t mean that menstrual hygiene management (MHM) is an issue that can be overlooked by those working in development. It’s important to recognise that this affects women and girls’ health, dignity and confidence, as well as their participation in education, the community and the economy.”

A-men(struation) to that.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “That Crime of the Month

  1. Sara

    Wholeheartedly agree; what are the solutions? Getting governments to act or NGOs or appealing to the Corporate Responsibility department at Tampax? We can all talk but I just wonder what should be done?

    Like

    Reply
  2. zefword Post author

    Action very important – but I think the words are, too. Such a taboo subject even in so-called developed countries. I’m not sure what I think, yet, about some bold attempts to open the issue up in general – ie Rupi Kaur’s pictures, censured by Instagram: https://news.artnet.com/in-brief/instagram-slammed-for-censoring-period-283123

    I didn’t bring that into this article because it feels like two different debates, and yet a first step to actually getting the research and resources necessary to tackle MHM in low-income countries (the challenge does seem simple to solve) must be for women and men to be able to talk about periods openly (and positively).

    Otherwise, as stuff we can do from here: déjà reading this and knowing the problem exists is good. But I agree, we need to do more. Support the 28 May international day; donate to 50cents or other orgs; spread the word; lobby governments or NGOs to take up the flambeau. Other concrete ideas, anyone else?

    Like

    Reply
  3. Sara

    50 cents sounds worthwhile but wonder if charities with a strong presence like Medecins sans frotieres, Oxfam etc could carry the torch more. Surely just as we do clothes collections for Emmaus and the like, charities with a presence in those countries (and the resources to send the stuff over/distribute it) could collect donated unused packets of Tampax? Should the manufacturing companies be targeted? Agree re education too, which again is where the big charities come in…

    Like

    Reply
  4. Danielle

    Thank you SO much for writing this funny, relatable and heavily insightful piece. We are WASH United, the NGO that initiated 28 May, Menstrual Hygiene Day (www.menstrualhygieneday.org) and are thrilled to say that, yes, things are changing. And not at a snail’s pace.

    Since 2014, over 300 organisations have joined the MH Day partner network, countless articles have been written and social media (Instagram, videos, etc.) shared, and most importantly, MHM policy advocacy IS happening at the national and international levels. Canada has dumped the sanitary napkin tax. Kenya, Uganda and India are all working on including MHM guidelines into their official education and WASH guidelines.

    The issue moving forward is how best do we sustain this momentum?

    The first and most obvious is to TALK ABOUT IT. The less talk about things, the less likely they are to be solved. So let’s keep talking. And let’s include men and boys into the conversation! There is no reason to keep this a women’s issue since it affects whole societies and populations of people.

    If you’re in joining the conversation and helping us shape this movement moving forward, I invite you to email me (danielle.keiser@wash-united.org), join the MH Day Momentum FB group (https://www.facebook.com/groups/MHDayMomentum/) and / or sign up for the quarterly newsletter ‘Keeping the Flow Going’: http://wash-united.us6.list-manage2.com/subscribe?u=688f521ff208cdfdce6a49839&id=9150ee436a.

    Your voice is amazing – you need to keep writing about this in your unique and persuasive tone… and aim for the bigger media outlets!!!!

    Like

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s